Paul “PJ” Fenui Jr.
Serving New Jersey & Florida
He is a Realtor-Associate® specializing in the purchase and sale of residences and investment properties within Northern New Jersey. PJ prides himself on his profound knowledge of this market area regarding school districts, neighborhood information, and related services (i.e., mortgage, insurance, and inspection information).
Thus, he provides his clients with all the pertinent information they need when buying or selling in these areas and is able to adeptly guide them throughout any decision-making process. Prior to his career in real estate, PJ graduated from Montclair State University with a degree in Business Administration with a concentration in Entrepreneurship.
New Jersey & Florida
Active Under Contract
$2,750,000
73 Treadwell Ave, Chatham Twp, NJ 07940
For Sale
$2,350,000
9 Travis Lane, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$2,150,000
7 Travis Lane, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$2,150,000
11 Travis Lane, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$2,150,000
4 Travis Lane, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
Active Under Contract
$2,150,000
12 Travis Lane, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$2,150,000
5 Travis Lane, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$2,050,000
2 Travis Lane, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$2,050,000
8 Travis Lane, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$2,050,000
10 Travis Lane, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$2,050,000
3 Travis Lane, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
Active Under Contract
$2,050,000
1 Travis Lane, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$2,050,000
6 Travis Lane, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$1,850,000
5 Francesca Ct, East Hanover Twp, NJ 07936
Coming Soon
$1,225,000
18 Howland Ter, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$1,200,000
96 Macculloch Ave, Morristown Town, NJ 07960
Active Under Contract
$1,199,000
1 Buckley Hill Rd, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
Active Under Contract
$999,000
2 Fairway Ave, West Orange Twp, NJ 07052
For Sale
$999,000
34 Lord William Penn Dr, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
Active Under Contract
$985,000
3 Aster Ter, Mendham Boro, NJ 07945
For Sale
$964,990
16 Remington Ct 16, Howell Twp, NJ 07727
For Sale
$939,990
18 Remington Ct 18, Howell Twp, NJ 07727
Active Under Contract
$899,000
21 Hewlett Rd, Montville Twp, NJ 07082
For Sale
$899,000
119 Shady Ln, Randolph Twp, NJ 07869
For Sale
$899,000
92 Hillcrest Ave, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$895,000
111 Carriage Hill Way, Branchburg Twp, NJ 08853
For Sale
$879,990
22 Remington Ct 22, Howell Twp, NJ 07727
Active Under Contract
$879,900
3 Red Oak Ln, Rockaway Twp, NJ 07866
Active Under Contract
$840,000
76 Keats Way, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$835,000
6 Dorothy Dr, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$799,990
12 Remington Ct 12, Howell Twp, NJ 07727
For Sale
$799,000
11 Hazel St 1-2, Morristown Town, NJ 07960
For Sale
$799,000
20 Lark Ln, Jefferson Twp, NJ 07438
Coming Soon
$790,000
22 Nottingham Ct, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$779,000
108 W Hanover Ave, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
Active Under Contract
$760,000
31 Twombly Ct, Morristown Town, NJ 07960
For Sale
$749,900
138 Shongum Rd, Denville Twp, NJ 07834
For Sale
$749,000
20 Mill Rd, Morris Twp, NJ 07950
Pending
$745,000
11 Hazel St 1-2, Morristown Town, NJ 07960
For Sale
$739,000
70 Keats Way, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$699,000
45 Sunset Rd, Bloomingdale Boro, NJ 07403
Active Under Contract
$689,000
3 Woodlawn Ter, Cedar Grove Twp, NJ 07009
Active Under Contract
$625,000
23 Hancock Dr, Morris Twp, NJ 07960
For Sale
$619,000
12 Highview Ave, Hanover Twp, NJ 07927
Active Under Contract
$610,000
28 Berkeley Sq, Watchung Boro, NJ 07922
For Sale
$599,000
9 Delmar Ave, Morris Twp, NJ 07950
For Sale
$585,000
18 Guilford Ct, Parsippany - Troy Hills Twp, NJ 07950
For Sale
$580,000
37 Woodmont Dr, Randolph Twp, NJ 07869
Active Under Contract
$575,000
197 Lake Shore Dr, Parsippany - Troy Hills Twp, NJ 07034
Active Under Contract
$565,000
38 Park St 24E E, Florham Park Boro, NJ 07932
PJ Fenui provided exceptional service during the sale of my house. He is very knowledgeable about the market, comps, marketing, pricing strategy, processes, etc. His level of service was amazing. He went above and beyond to ensure that the process went smoothly and kept me informed at every step. I highly recommend PJ, as he is a very knowledgeable, high-energy professional.
PJ Fenui provided exceptional service during the sale of my house. He is very knowledgeable about the market, comps, marketing, pricing strategy, processes, etc. His level of service was amazing. He went above and beyond to ensure that the process went smoothly and kept me informed at every step. I highly recommend PJ, as he is a very knowledgeable, high-energy professional.
I highly recommend PJ Fenui as your real estate agent. He is professional, and he has the knowledge to sell your property. He had all the estimates, prices, professional quotes; he has the knowledge of the paperwork the lawyer will need, and the understanding of all documents for the sale of the property. He understands the market at the current time, along with interest rates, and keeps the client (me) calm and worry-free. He was great with the understanding of the mindset of the buyers.
I highly recommend PJ Fenui as your real estate agent. He is professional, and he has the knowledge to sell your property. He had all the estimates, prices, professional quotes; he has the knowledge of the paperwork the lawyer will need, and the understanding of all documents for the sale of the property. He understands the market at the current time, along with interest rates, and keeps the client (me) calm and worry-free. He was great with the understanding of the mindset of the buyers.
PJ was a phenomenal real estate agent! He went above and beyond and was by our side every step of the way, leading up to a swift and prosperous sale. He made us feel calm and secure because we knew we were in good hands. Any time we had a question or concern, he responded to us quickly.
PJ was a phenomenal real estate agent! He went above and beyond and was by our side every step of the way, leading up to a swift and prosperous sale. He made us feel calm and secure because we knew we were in good hands. Any time we had a question or concern, he responded to us quickly.
PJ is the best! He was with us for two years during this housing market frenzy. He was patient and kind throughout the entire home-buying journey. After seeing 39 houses, we finally landed on a house that checked nearly all the boxes. The seller's attorney said she was impressed with PJ’s offer letter, and we believe if it weren’t for PJ’s coordination and attention to detail, we wouldn’t have our offer accepted. PJ always makes himself available to us, even when he’s away. We appreciate his responsiveness. He never hesitates to answer any questions; a question was never too big or too small to ask, and was always available on the phone for further discussion. PJ works with integrity and has the client’s best interest in mind. Simply put, PJ is dependable and on top of things. The process was streamlined perfectly from offer acceptance, home inspection, attorney review, and closing. He even helped us handle a mishap that happened after closing. You can’t ask for anything better than that. We love our new house, and PJ was the best part of our experience.
PJ is the best! He was with us for two years during this housing market frenzy. He was patient and kind throughout the entire home-buying journey. After seeing 39 houses, we finally landed on a house that checked nearly all the boxes. The seller's attorney said she was impressed with PJ’s offer letter, and we believe if it weren’t for PJ’s coordination and attention to detail, we wouldn’t have our offer accepted. PJ always makes himself available to us, even when he’s away. We appreciate his responsiveness. He never hesitates to answer any questions; a question was never too big or too small to ask, and was always available on the phone for further discussion. PJ works with integrity and has the client’s best interest in mind. Simply put, PJ is dependable and on top of things. The process was streamlined perfectly from offer acceptance, home inspection, attorney review, and closing. He even helped us handle a mishap that happened after closing. You can’t ask for anything better than that. We love our new house, and PJ was the best part of our experience.
Selling our home, which has been an integral part of our live,s is not an easy task. The whole process of finding a trustworthy realtor that can direct us from staging our home, going through the preparations for the open house, gathering all the pertinent documents, and dealing with all the legalities is exactly what PJ Fenui did for us. He has truly been an outstanding realtor who took us by the hand and guided us throughout this complicated process. PJ kept us informed with every step and provided details of what to expect in the upcoming events to put us at ease until the closing day, which happened very quickly and seemingly easily. If anyone is ever in need of a realtor, Randy and O’Hara highly recommend PJ Fenui, extraordinaire, to assist you.
Selling our home, which has been an integral part of our live,s is not an easy task. The whole process of finding a trustworthy realtor that can direct us from staging our home, going through the preparations for the open house, gathering all the pertinent documents, and dealing with all the legalities is exactly what PJ Fenui did for us. He has truly been an outstanding realtor who took us by the hand and guided us throughout this complicated process. PJ kept us informed with every step and provided details of what to expect in the upcoming events to put us at ease until the closing day, which happened very quickly and seemingly easily. If anyone is ever in need of a realtor, Randy and O’Hara highly recommend PJ Fenui, extraordinaire, to assist you.
Before starting the home-buying process, my fiancé and I were very skeptical of realtors. They have tremendous influence over what is likely the biggest financial decision you will ever make, and we were genuinely afraid of working with someone who might take advantage of us. After sharing our hopes of buying a home with friends, family, and coworkers, PJ was recommended to us by someone we deeply trust. With that endorsement, we decided to meet him—and we are so grateful that we did. Our first meeting with PJ was on September 24th, 2025. We had no idea we would be closing exactly two months later. As first-time home buyers, we knew nothing. We honestly thought it would take at least a year before we’d feel confident enough to buy. But from the moment we started working with PJ, we began building real knowledge. His home-buyer’s guide laid out the process step by step, and we referred to it constantly. It kept us grounded through every stage. PJ is relentless in his commitment to finding the right home for you. He never made us feel like we were asking too much—even though we wanted to see many more houses than an hour from where he lives. Early on, he warned us that we might not get the first house we fell in love with, and he was right. We made an offer on a home we adored, but the seller played games, delayed responses, and tried to squeeze more out of us. We submitted our best and final offer, and it wasn’t enough. It was a crushing moment, and we genuinely felt like giving up. That Friday night, PJ asked what our plans were for the next day and whether we wanted to see more houses. We told him we had nothing saved because we were convinced our offer would be accepted. But that same night, we sent him several listings—and somehow, he worked magic, booking us five showings for the very next day. One of those houses became the home we now own. If PJ hadn’t pushed us to keep looking, we would have missed out on what truly feels like our dream home and, hopefully, our forever home. Another huge benefit of working with PJ is his network. His trusted home inspector, mortgage broker, and attorney made us feel like we had a true “super team” around us. Every professional he connected us with was outstanding, and it’s clear why he keeps them close. I can say with full honesty that PJ was the best realtor we could have asked for. He made the entire experience not just smooth, but genuinely special. He is incredibly responsive—late nights, weekends, even holidays—always just a text away. Despite juggling many clients, he always made us feel like we were his top priority. Lastly, something deeply meaningful to us: we are first-generation college graduates, the children of immigrants, raised in inner-city apartments. Sharing this experience with our families was important, and PJ welcomed them at every showing. He never made us feel like a burden. That kindness is something we will never forget. We sincerely want to thank PJ for helping us realize the American Dream.
Before starting the home-buying process, my fiancé and I were very skeptical of realtors. They have tremendous influence over what is likely the biggest financial decision you will ever make, and we were genuinely afraid of working with someone who might take advantage of us. After sharing our hopes of buying a home with friends, family, and coworkers, PJ was recommended to us by someone we deeply trust. With that endorsement, we decided to meet him—and we are so grateful that we did. Our first meeting with PJ was on September 24th, 2025. We had no idea we would be closing exactly two months later. As first-time home buyers, we knew nothing. We honestly thought it would take at least a year before we’d feel confident enough to buy. But from the moment we started working with PJ, we began building real knowledge. His home-buyer’s guide laid out the process step by step, and we referred to it constantly. It kept us grounded through every stage. PJ is relentless in his commitment to finding the right home for you. He never made us feel like we were asking too much—even though we wanted to see many more houses than an hour from where he lives. Early on, he warned us that we might not get the first house we fell in love with, and he was right. We made an offer on a home we adored, but the seller played games, delayed responses, and tried to squeeze more out of us. We submitted our best and final offer, and it wasn’t enough. It was a crushing moment, and we genuinely felt like giving up. That Friday night, PJ asked what our plans were for the next day and whether we wanted to see more houses. We told him we had nothing saved because we were convinced our offer would be accepted. But that same night, we sent him several listings—and somehow, he worked magic, booking us five showings for the very next day. One of those houses became the home we now own. If PJ hadn’t pushed us to keep looking, we would have missed out on what truly feels like our dream home and, hopefully, our forever home. Another huge benefit of working with PJ is his network. His trusted home inspector, mortgage broker, and attorney made us feel like we had a true “super team” around us. Every professional he connected us with was outstanding, and it’s clear why he keeps them close. I can say with full honesty that PJ was the best realtor we could have asked for. He made the entire experience not just smooth, but genuinely special. He is incredibly responsive—late nights, weekends, even holidays—always just a text away. Despite juggling many clients, he always made us feel like we were his top priority. Lastly, something deeply meaningful to us: we are first-generation college graduates, the children of immigrants, raised in inner-city apartments. Sharing this experience with our families was important, and PJ welcomed them at every showing. He never made us feel like a burden. That kindness is something we will never forget. We sincerely want to thank PJ for helping us realize the American Dream.
Areas of Expertise
Denville is a highly desirable Morris County town known as the Hub of the County, offering a walkable downtown, top-rated schools, scenic parks, and convenient NJ Transit access. With a strong community feel, diverse housing options, and easy commuting to New York City, Denville is an ideal place to live, work, and invest in New Jersey real estate.
Read MoreMorris Plains is a desirable Morris County community known for its small-town charm, convenient NJ Transit train access, and close proximity to Morristown. The borough features quiet residential neighborhoods, a walkable downtown, local shops and restaurants, and well-maintained parks. With a mix of single-family homes, townhomes, and condos, Morris Plains appeals to commuters, downsizers, and long-term homeowners seeking a peaceful yet connected lifestyle in Northern New Jersey.
Read MoreHere’s a very short website description for Woodland Park, NJ, based on verified sources: Woodland Park, New Jersey is a small, scenic borough in Passaic County, known for its lush green landscapes, strong community feel, and local landmarks like Garret Mountain Reservation. Originally incorporated as West Paterson in 1914, the town adopted the name Woodland Park in 2009 to reflect its natural surroundings.
Read MoreWharton, NJ is a historic Morris County borough known for its roots in the 18th‑century iron industry, the Morris Canal, and its vibrant small‑town charm. Located just off Routes 15, 46, and 80, Wharton blends rich industrial heritage with beautiful parks, community events, and easy access to North Jersey’s scenic highlands
Read MorePJ (Paul) Fenui Jr.
REALTOR®
About Me
We need more information to provide an accurate estimate for this address. Local expert PJ (Paul) Fenui Jr. will reach out shortly or you can schedule a consultation now.
Property Address
Address
Luxury Presence Home Value is the current estimated value of this home. It is calculated from a comprehensive database which encompasses properties from all 50 states, covering 99% of the US population, and valuation software developed by Automated Valuation Model (AVM) Analytics.
Blog Posts
Stay informed with timely real estate insights, market updates, and practical tips for navigating today’s New Jersey and Florida markets. From buying and selling strategies to agent-focused advice, PJ’s blog is designed to keep you one step ahead.
Trust him to guide your home purchase or sale with strong local insight, proven negotiation skills, and dedicated service. With his focused approach and responsive support, he helps make your real estate journey smooth and successful.